- Churning The Sea Of Time
- Danielson: A Family Movie
- Darkon
- Ferry Tales
- Generation Meds
- Hooked: The Legend of Demetrius 'Hook' Mitchell
- Horns and Halos
- King of the Hill
- Knocking
- Occupation: Dreamland
- Reel Works
- Sentenced Home
- Shadow Company
- The Breast Cancer Diaries
- The Ground Truth
- The Making of a Martyr
- The Trials of Darryl Hunt
- The World's Best Prom
- Summer Camp
- Media That Matters
- Going Back to New Orleans
- Manufacturing Dissent
My Thoughts on Knocking
About a year and a half later, I saw Knocking in its almost completed form for the first time. I was really surprised. I didn't know what to expect. I had this gut fear that the filmmaker was pulling a fast one and actually made a negative documentary about Witnesses (this was before I had met the producers, Joel Engardio and Tom Shepard). Fortunately, it was the opposite. In fact, the film was completely different from anything I had imagined.
Knocking is about people. About Seth Thomas' crisis of life and faith and his family's struggles. About Joseph Kempler's beliefs in spite of the pain he faced and his desire to connect with those of his family that he let go. Knocking tells the stories few people outside the Witness community know about. It shows examples of challenges that every Witness faces at some point in their lives.
Another strong theme of the film that many are in the dark about is the huge impact Jehovah's Witnesses have had in the field of civil liberties. Though only seeking the legal right to spread our message, the Witnesses shaped the way we look at freedom of speech as it is today. It's largely unknown, however, because it was never made a large political spectacle. Rather, it was a less glamorous battle fought in the courtrooms. Because of that, many simply have no knowledge of any of this. Knocking makes sure they do.
Knocking is a film that can really be misunderstood by those who haven't seen it, much like the people it documents. When it was nearing completion, a simple Google of "Knocking" and "documentary" pulled up a slew of anti-Jehovah's Witnesses sites that pretty much exploded in a furor over the film, railing it as a "puff-production" and a even trying to prevent PBS from airing it (include an online petition that, as of yet, has 0 signatures). Naturally, much of this came up before the film had even been finished (go figure).
On the other end of the spectrum, there are my fellow Witnesses who are suspicious of the film because it's independently made. They feel this way because the media has rarely treated Witnesses well, especially when addressing subjects such as political neutrality and blood transfusions. There are those who may never watch Knocking for that reason, and I can only say that they will miss out on an encouraging and moving film.
I can't even begin to imagine what the filmmakers had to go through to make this film. I suppose they had to do things such as convincing the Thomas', the Kemplers, and Lillian Gobitas' to share their story, convincing the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society (the legal entity of Jehovah's Witnesses) to provide cooperation with the film, and on top of all that, convince somebody with funding that this was a story worth telling.
I'm so glad they did, however, epecially Joel Engardio. I'd imagine he disagrees with Jehovah's Witnesses in a number of areas, yet he made this film to show the world the reality; what Witnesses are like behind the "knocking." Our faith is one we not only preach by, but live by.
Reader Comments
(Page 1)2. It is remarkable how many Supreme Court Cases Jehovah's Witnesses have won. I am a Jehovah's Witness and although I am aware many cases went to the Supreme Court I never knew just how many due to the fact that they have been presented over decades and we have never made a media issue about them.
Ellen at 2:46PM on May 6th 2007
3. Thank you so much for your in-depth profile of these JW's who, though imperfect & ordinary, exhibit extraordinary, God-assisted strength daily. Seldom do we find "out-siders" interested in portraying us in a positive light. Before studying the Bible with JW's, I never really knew about the Witnesses who were in the Nazi Concentration Camps...I thought there were only Jews. I value the organizations' stand on political neutrality & pray
that others are able to see that if everyone in the world would obey Jehovah's laws....wars would
cease IMMEDIATELY. Sincere thanks to those of you who worked on this project for getting the word out. It is a marvelous thing for a man to see "good for his hard work". You have done good !!
Edith M. Brown at 12:50AM on May 26th 2007
4. it's a shame that the Jehovah's Witnesses will likely bring more people into their cult with this film. They have ignored the bible in front of them and take the Watchtower Magazine for fact. Not only does the magazine contradict the King James Bible, but at times their New World Translation as well.
I hope whoever reads this will open their eyes. I know it's hard I used to be one of you.
please visit "www.freeminds.org" your soul is at stake.
Rick Doza at 1:19PM on May 28th 2007
5. The guy above me need's to get a life!
Anyway's thanks for the positive info on jehovah's witnesses!:-)
Jess at 2:43PM on May 28th 2007
6. hi i know you get of lot of folk having negatives thoughts regarding the wathctower religion.
but what i really do care about is the fact that god made the earth for us to live in.?did he not? why did he put us here if heaven was the best place to be? and in my veiw after reading the bible it is a very good life to live. i would love to live in a peaceful new world
but so many are dead set against this they say a of negative things that are intened to put off any one favoring the wittnesess but i do wish they would say somthing positve about why are we here why we die, we need answers who out thier tries to get the bible way of life right ? why did god let noah live for over 900 years? and adam lived over 900 years also, so then prove yourself to be a good fruit
and bring something positve to the forum for us all to benifit from
thanks
john
john at 8:38AM on Jun 7th 2007

1. I have had some hesitation with a few friends to view this documentary. However, I have directed them to the outstanding website on PBS/Independent Lens.
Even if they do not view the program that evening, once the DVD is purchased by friends (like me) and the word spreads the DVD will probably make the rounds and into the libraries of most Jehovah's Witnesses just like Purple Triangles did.
R Manetti at 6:23PM on May 5th 2007